Diane Ravitch takes to task in a blog post today a recent Associated Press Research Poll for its findings that "Parents back standardized testing."
Unfortunately, Ms. Ravitch also takes the parents to task. Decidedly not good form — and pointedly missing the point of what the parents really want.
She asserts, "The headline says parents support 'high-stakes testing,' but nothing in the story supports that assertion," which is not exactly accurate and shows a disconnect from what the parents really are saying in the survey:
"A full 93 percent of parents say standardized tests should be used to identify areas where students need extra help. Smaller majorities think such tests should be used to measure school quality, evaluate teachers or determine whether or not students are promoted or can graduate."
Showing posts with label Common Core. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Common Core. Show all posts
Sunday, August 18, 2013
Saturday, August 10, 2013
The New Math is Old Again ... is New Again ... is Older Again
Why, if there's more than one way, do we teach only one way?
My son rang me up the other day to give a heads-up about an All Things Considered (NPR) segment "Common Core Curriculum Brings Big Shifts To Math Instruction." Its 269 seconds nicely encapsulates why our monolithic one-size-fits-all public education model is flawed in theory and in practice.
The segment focuses on Common Core's decision that, to best foster an understanding of place value, a horizontal method ("regrouping") of addition should replace the "vertical" Standard algorithm for second graders (the Standard method doesn't go away, it just gets delayed until fourth grade). The show's guests do an admirable job of jousting the pros and cons of this move given the soundbite nature of the encounter (a more involved treatment appeared in The Grey Lady this past June ("The Faulty Logic of the 'Math Wars'"); reading the appended Comments is a must).
My son rang me up the other day to give a heads-up about an All Things Considered (NPR) segment "Common Core Curriculum Brings Big Shifts To Math Instruction." Its 269 seconds nicely encapsulates why our monolithic one-size-fits-all public education model is flawed in theory and in practice.
The segment focuses on Common Core's decision that, to best foster an understanding of place value, a horizontal method ("regrouping") of addition should replace the "vertical" Standard algorithm for second graders (the Standard method doesn't go away, it just gets delayed until fourth grade). The show's guests do an admirable job of jousting the pros and cons of this move given the soundbite nature of the encounter (a more involved treatment appeared in The Grey Lady this past June ("The Faulty Logic of the 'Math Wars'"); reading the appended Comments is a must).
Friday, August 9, 2013
Speaking (Learning) Truth to About Power
Speaking truth to about power, Ms. Teresa Thayer Snyder, Superintendent of the Voorheesville (New York) Central School District, has produced a "Commentary on Math & ELA Results" letter to parents that's gone viral (I've encountered it repeatedly on Facebook and Google+ today). No surprise, since it's the type of standardized testing jeremiad that educators (FB) LIKE, as Superintendent Snyder takes the New York State Education Department to task for its "missives" about the recent low test scores across the state "because they reek of the self-serving mentality the ‘powers that be’ have thrust upon our students and parents."
But I think the superintendent has missed out on an opportunity.
But I think the superintendent has missed out on an opportunity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


